I had them uploaded as a private album through my user CP, I've changed it to public, any luck?
Try soldering pin OBD2.15 down. Be prepared to unsloder it if it stops working
Pin OBD2.9 is RPM, don't need that.
Pin OBD2.14 is CAN LOW J-2284 don't need that, not supported on the car and 16-20 adaptor.
Dunno about OBD2.12 but don't need it either.
OK, I have tried soldering down pin OBD2.15 and found that I still had no access to ZKE & KOMBI modules. I was still able to access DME & HVAC though like before.
NET result = no change.
if it was that easy don't you think ebay would be awash with them in that guise in the first place? there would be no need to sell more expensive ADS interfaces to start with, twas obvious it was never gonna do anything.....
The ADS interface is well documented in the BMW document ADS_DOCU.pdf and easily replicable with about three more active parts than a regular USB OBD2 adaptor.
Why eBay is not awash with them - well your guess is as good as mine - but it's a very simple device.
EDIT: Here is BMW's single snippet description of the difference between an ADS interface and an OBD2 one.Not impossible to replicate. Easily achievable with transistors or twin transceivers with an ENABLE/DISABLE line.DTR control line for switching the transmission line to the vehicle
DTR =-12V: Send to RxD
DTR = +12 V: Send to TxD
The EDIABAS software may or may not need to see it's own Tx echo on the RS232 Rx path when DTR=-12V (because RxD is always connected and you Tx on it). Easily achievable with twin K line transcivers or perhaps a diode.
hence the switchboxes refered to earlier, it makes more economic sense to the ppl that make them to make something that will interface with both earlier and the later system, thus i suppose creating a broader marketing base to make them worth making in the first place and limiting the costs of producing them...
Like I mentioned before I have already ordered the OBD/ADS switch box you linked previously and I thank you for your recommendation but if I can assist joylove with his attempts to find a more affordable solution then I shall.
The ADS interface is fully compatible with cars up until about 2008 when they added an Ethernet connection. I think the K line connection persists in those cars too, for backwards compatibility, but I don't own one to test.
Remeber, the additional function in an ADS adaptor is the DTR line that routes data to the L line. If Eidabas leaves that line high permenantly, the adaptor performs like any cheapo USB OBD2 adaptor, routing all Tx/Rx data to OBD2.7 K line. The fact it needs a DTR line is why you need a proper serial port, and it needs to be on COM1/3F38h/IRQ11 we have found because there is no ini file for the ADS that allows you to use COM2, 3 etc.
Sure you have ignition sensing with ADS, but when you have the ignition off it's pretty obvious as none of the modules respond
When Ediabas holds the DTR line at +12V for E39, E46, X5, E90, the ADS interface behaves exactly like any OBD2 adaptor.
As for building a custom adaptor and whether it is commercially viable, I think enough BMWs have been made since 1985ish when OBD came along to make it commercially viable. Enough E36 owners have issues with adaptors alone to sell a few hundred worldwide, especially if it was USB enabled. Unfortunately someone usually has to do the work first, before it gets reverse engineered and copied in China.
|« Previous Thread | Next Thread »|